Search
Evaluating
Ideas: Multivoting
Multivoting is a process for narrowing down a list of brainstormed items by indicating a priority for each item on the list. This decision-making step is especially useful when a group has generated lots of ideas [see last week's Defining the Vision activity] and wants to get a sense of the relative priority of each item
In last week's entry, we used as an example defining a vision for a new middle school. Let's say the process produced a list of 32 ideas that were part of participants' vision of this ideal new school. Now it is time to narrow down the list and give participants a chance to express their priorities
First, make sure there is clarity about the meaning of each item on the list. (Where there is agreement to do so, you might even combine ideas that are similar in meaning.) Then explain that in multivoting every participant gets the same number of votes.
|
A good rule of thumb: divide the number of ideas on your list by 3 to come up with the number of votes each participant will get. For very long lists, you might divide by 5.
Since our example group came up with 32 ideas, we will divide by 5. Each participant will have 6 votes.
Write on the board or flipchart a list of criteria that participants will want to consider as they make their choices. In our example, those criteria might include
- items that are most important to you;
- items that would best serve the students; or
- items that are most likely to be approved.
Decide and be clear as to whether people can "stack" their votes on items (give items of top priority more than one vote) or whether they need to use each vote for a separate item.
Then invite everyone to come up to the charts to mark their top choices.
Once the votes are tallied, be clear about what will happen next with this list. For example,
- Will all items be presented to the planning committee listed in priority order?
- Will only ideas that received the most votes be presented?
- Will ideas that received x number of votes or more be presented?
For more information about the multivoting strategy and other strategies for setting priorities and a vision, order your copy of Great Meetings! Great Results today.
NEXT WEEK IN GREAT MEETINGS: Pick 3 - Drop 3 is another tool that helps groups narrow down a list of ideas.
|
EW Lesson Plans
Submit your own lesson plan for a chance to receive a FREE $50 Classroom Supplies Gift Card!
> Learn more!
Chatter
Trending
Hot Diggity Dog
Build grammar skills using this activity and answer key for an article about one of America's favorite foods, the hot dog!
Click for a PDF (portable document format) printable version of this Every-Day Edit activity.
Scroll down or click for work sheet text and answer key.
Click for our archive of Every-Day Edit activities from previous weeks.
Click for Ideas for Using Every-Day Edit in the classroom.
Activity Key
Uncorrected Text
Did you now that July is national Hot Dog Month. The average American eat 70 hot dogs each year. New York City is the hot dog “capital.” More then 105 million dogs was sold there in 2004. Mustard is the topping of choice among people who are more than 35 years old, but most younger eators prefer ketchup. Some people even like they’re hot dogs served in ice cream! The largest hotdog ever made was 1,996 feet long
Answer Key
Did you know that July is National Hot Dog Month? The average American eats 70 hot dogs each year. New York City is the hot dog "capital." More than 105 million dogs were sold there in 2004. Mustard is the topping of choice among people who are more than 35 years old, but most younger eaters prefer ketchup. Some people even like their hot dogs served in ice cream! The largest hot dog ever made was 1,996 feet long.
Article by Gary Hopkins
Education World® Editor in Chief
Copyright © 2005 Education World
07/2005
Subject: ELA- Reading
Grade: 5
Lesson Objective: To read unfamiliar multisyllabic words in and out of context
Common Core Standard: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RF.5.3.A- Use combined knowledge of all letter-sound correspondences, syllabication patterns, and morphology (e.g., roots and affixes) to read accurately unfamiliar multisyllabic words in context and out of context.
Materials:
Printable Sudent Worksheet Handout
Starter:
Say:
When you come to a word that you do not know when you are reading, what do you do? (Allow the students to answer.)
Main:
Say:
We all find words that we do not know when we are reading. There are different ways that we can figure out a word that we do not know.
You can sound the word out. You are reading books that are harder and longer now and sounding out a word is not as easy as it used to be!
You should start by figuring out the syllable patterns. You know that every syllable has a vowel sound.
The different syllable patterns are closed syllables and open syllables.
A closed syllable ends with a consonant and usually has a short vowel sound. For example, plan-et.
An open syllable ends with a long vowel sound. For example, pa-per.
In addition to the syllables in a word, you should think about the affixes. An affix is added to the beginning or end of a root word to form different words.
For example, the root word scope can be changed to microscope or telescope by adding different affixes.
Now, you are going to be doing a worksheet so that you can practice reading difficult words. You will read the paragraph. There are words that are underlined in the paragraph, those are the difficult words.
After you have read the whole paragraph and tried the hard words, you are going to find a partner and take turns reading the list of words at the bottom of the worksheet to each other.
Does anyone have any questions?
Feedback:
Say:
Who would like to share how to read the words? (Allow the students to share and go over the answers.)
Written by Kimberly Greacen, Education World® Contributing Writer
Kimberly is an educator with extensive experience in curriculum writing and developing instructional materials to align with Common Core State Standards and Bloom's Taxonomy.
Copyright© 2019 Education World
Subject: ELA- Reading
Grade: 5
Lesson Objective: To explain what part of a text means while drawing inferences about that text
Common Core Standard: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.5.1- Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text.
Materials:
Printable Student Worksheet Handout
Starter:
Say:
What are some situations in which you draw inferences? (Allow the students to answer.)
Main:
Say:
We all draw inferences. We do it every day when we are listening to someone speaking, when we are reading and when we are watching other people.
An inference is a conclusion that we make using things that we already know (prior knowledge) and new information.
An example of an inference is a mother giving her young child blueberries to try. The child puts the blueberry in its mouth, chews it and then spits it out. The mother can infer that the child does not like the blueberry.
Sometimes when we are reading, the text does not tell us exactly what we need to know. When that happens, we need to draw an inference.
A good strategy for drawing inferences is to think “It says, I know, so…”
When you do this, it helps you to think about what the text is telling you and what you already know. You are then able to draw an inference.
Sometimes, when you are explaining how you found the information that used when drawing your inference, you need to quote the text that you are using.
When quoting a text, you must use the author’s exact words and you should always use quotation marks.
If you are quoting a text from a book, you should always include the page number so that others can find the quote.
Now, you are going to be reading a few paragraphs from a book. After you have finished reading, there are questions for you to answer. Remember to use the inference strategy and remember how to quote a text.
Does anyone have any questions?
Feedback:
Say:
Who would like to share their answers? (Allow the students to share and go over the answers.)
Written by Kimberly Greacen, Education World® Contributing Writer
Kimberly is an educator with extensive experience in curriculum writing and developing instructional materials to align with Common Core State Standards and Bloom's Taxonomy.
Copyright© 2019 Education World
Receive timely lesson ideas and PD tips
Sitemap
|
Sign up for our free weekly newsletter and receive
top education news, lesson ideas, teaching tips and more!
COPYRIGHT 1996-2016 BY EDUCATION WORLD, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
COPYRIGHT 1996 - 2019 BY EDUCATION WORLD, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
75 Mill Street, Colchester, CT 06415
