Home > "Best Of" Series > 1997 > Chalk Talk Challenge I > Questions and Results > Week Three

W E E K     T H R E E

 

QUESTION 1

Physical Contact -- Physical contact in schools, particularly student-student, has become a tricky issue of late. In terms of adults touching children, do you believe that:

A -- Due to past abuses, and the current atmosphere, teachers should be completely undemonstrative. No matter what the intention, contact can be misinterpreted.

B -- Not touching children under any circumstances is akin to neglect, especially for very young children who might pick up the message that expressions of warmth are wrong.

C -- Teachers should generally be restrained, but should use their judgement and consider the following in each situation where touching might occur: "Would I allow someone I wasn't close with to touch *me* in that way?"

D -- I don't have an opinion on this issue.

The Results:

ABCD
5%32%61%2%

 

QUESTION 2

Detracking -- Over the past few years, many schools have moved toward "detracking." That is, they no longer categorize students based on ability. What do you think about detracking?

A -- It's a good idea. Intelligence is developmental, not fixed, and cannot necessarily be measured by an I.Q. score, especially when it comes to young children. Diversity in the classroom promotes learning for *all* students.

B -- It is not a good idea. To help each child achieve his own potential, we need to separate students based on their capacity to learn. Otherwise, the slow students will be left behind, and the bright students will not reach their potential.

C -- Detracking won't automatically solve the problems plaguing schools today, but it may begin to incite much-needed change in the philosophy and structure of the current school system.

D -- I don't have an opinion on this issue.

The Results:

ABCD
23%32%41%4%

 

QUESTION 3

Teacher Pay -- A November 1996 report from the National Center for Education Statistics says that "teacher salaries tend to be low relative to those earned by similarly qualified individuals in other professions." You think that teacher pay:

A -- Is grossly inadequate. For one thing, the time a teacher spends in class is only about 3/4 of his or her work week. For another, teachers are responsible for molding the nation's youth, and teacher pay should reflect the importance of this task.

B -- Is generally adequate. Teachers work shorter days and get summer vacations; they really shouldn't earn as much as executives who work longer hours and only get two weeks of vacation.

C -- Is adequate in some regions of the country, like the Northeast, for example, but inadequate in other regions, such as the South.

D -- I don't have an opinion on this issue.

The Results:

ABCD
66%9%21%4%