Education World examines the personal experiences
of children with ADHD, describes the disorder's symptoms, and explains
the three types of the disorder. Included: Recommended
guidelines for diagnosing ADHD.
The whispers and quiet chatter in Lori's classroom combined with the sounds
of the pencil sharpener, the lawn mower outside, and a group of students
passing in the hall. Those ambient sounds blurred into echoes so distracting
that Lori couldn't concentrate. That was how 11-year-old Lori (not her
real name) described what it was like in a classroom before taking stimulant
medication.
Lori's pediatrician diagnosed attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
The medication he prescribed helps Lori isolate all those sounds that blur
together, Lori tells her mother. It allows her to focus, which helps her
also deal with diagnosed learning disabilities.
Like Lori, Chris Kaplanek, now 18, also was diagnosed with ADHD when
he was in elementary school. He has a different type of ADHD. His disorder
pertains to excessive hyperactivity in combination with inattention. He
also has been diagnosed with a learning disability; that, in combination
with his ADHD, contributes to his low tolerance for frustration.
Without help in school and at home, Chris tells his mother, "I would
be a loser ... nowhere." His mother, Beth Kaplanek, is the volunteer president
of the board of directors of
Children and Adults With Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder
(CHADD).
Lori and Chris have different types of ADHD. Experts have identified
three subsets of the disorder: inattention, hyperactivity, and inattention
with hyperactivity. Regardless of the type, many children with ADHD commonly
report that images, sounds, and thoughts churn constantly in their minds,
distracting them. Those distractions make staying fixed on any one task
or activity nearly impossible. Some children with ADHD don't even hear
people speak because they are so distracted, according to the
American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (AACAP).
Others find that all those images create such frenzy for them that they
are unable to sit still, to pay attention to what is going on, or to plan
ahead. The core problem of ADHD, say experts, is that it affects all thought-processing
tasks.
"Chris is so scattered in his thoughts that he needs someone to coach
him through school," explained Beth Kaplanek. Although he has an IQ of
130, which is well above average, the combination of his disorders interferes
with his ability to learn in school, Kaplanek said. "Chris is not happy
he has it. He cries sometimes, and he doesn't understand why he has to
have it. But he says he tries to go inside himself and think about others
who have it tougher."
Many children with ADHD also suffer from learning disabilities, and
they find succeeding in school a struggle.
AACAP estimates that every teacher has at least one child with ADHD;
about 3 to 5 percent of children are affected with ADHD. However, the
www.aap.org American Academy of Pediatrics places that figure higher,
between 4 and 12 percent of all school-age children, making ADHD the most
common childhood neurobehavioral disorder.
Teachers are often the first persons to identify a child who may have
ADHD. "It's crazy we are asking teachers to diagnose that," said Jonathan
Michaelis, a clinical neuropsychologist and a clinical director of three
ADD Centers in Connecticut.
"Physicians must depend on what the teacher told a parent in order to
render a diagnosis," Michaelis told Education World. "The poor physician
has about 10 to 12 minutes to see a patient. That's all the time the insurance
company will give." A ten-minute evaluation doesn't cut it when a comprehensive
evaluation is needed, he said.
Because pediatricians and family physicians are more likely than psychiatrists
to make the diagnosis, the AAP issued
Diagnosis and Evaluation of the Child With Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity
Guidelines last May. The AAP designed the guidelines to provide a
standard for diagnosing ADHD in children six to 12 years old.
The AAP guidelines recommend the following:
- A child must exhibit at least six of nine symptoms of the criteria
defined by the American
Psychiatric Association.
- The child should demonstrate those symptoms in at least two settings.
- Those symptoms must be harmful to the child's academic or social
functioning for at least six months.
- The assessment requires evidence directly obtained from the classroom
teacher (or another school professional).
- An additional assessment should also be conducted for associated
(coexisting) conditions, such as learning disabilities and other mental
health or behavioral disorders.
If children don't display ADHD symptoms at home, then they don't have
ADHD, advises David B. Pruitt, past president of the American Academy
of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, in Your Child: What Every Parent
Needs to Know: What's Normal, What's Not, and When to Seek Help. The
problem may be that the children are bored, discouraged, restless, and
unable to follow instructions at school because they don't find the structure
or challenge in school appropriate for them, according to Pruitt. He recommends
that careful evaluation of children with school problems should include
assessments of possible learning disabilities or other emotional or neurological
disorders, such as depression or Tourette's syndrome.
Pruitt summarizes the symptoms of ADHD. He says the least common type
of ADHD is the hyperactivity subset. Children with hyperactivity tend
to blurt out answers in the classroom but are able to concentrate on their
tasks. They also may have difficulty sitting through a structured activity.
Hyperactive children are predominantly fidgety. Some are impulsive to
the point of being dangers to themselves. Others can be aggressive with
their classmates.
Children with the inattention subset are easily distracted in class
and are disorganized, but not hyperactive. They daydream, forget or lose
things, procrastinate with their assignments, and fail to complete their
work. Some have difficulty paying attention for more than a few minutes.
The third type is the most severe. These children have both the hyperactivity
and inattention components.
Research supports biological, genetic, and neuropsychological underpinnings
of ADHD, but no one is absolutely certain exactly what causes it, according
to the studies funded by the
National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH).
Studies have found a genetic component because ADHD runs in families.
About half of parents who had ADHD as a child will have a child with the
disorder.
In addition to the genetic element, imaging technology by NIMH researcher
F. Xavier Castellanos, found that children with ADHD have subtle brain
circuit abnormalities on the right side of the brain in the frontal lobe
just behind the forehead.
Castellanos also discovered that both sides of the brains of children
with ADHD are symmetrical. In children who do not have ADHD, the left
and right sides of their brains are not the same size and are not symmetrical;
the right side is larger than the left side in most people.
Many experts put forth a brain chemical imbalance theory that supports
a physiological basis for ADHD. This "dopamine theory" has gained a wide
following, according to the
Mental Health: A Report of the Surgeon General. The theory explains
that the reason stimulant medication is effective in children who have
ADHD is because stimulants increase the availability of the neurotransmitter
dopamine.
Although researchers have found brain abnormalities in children who
have ADHD, they have not found a clear reason. Some researchers have found
a correlation between children with ADHD and histories of prenatal and
birth complications. That correlation is leading researchers to speculate
that events in the womb and at birth may affect the normal development
of brain symmetry that may underlie ADHD.
Diane Weaver Dunne
Education World®
Copyright © 2005 Education World
Originally published 12/11/2000; updated 08/02/2005
|